We use the silver, black & bronze lids for all our 3-wicks jars. Never had a problem with scratches/rub marks and we order them by the case. Packaged well and secure.

These lids are great. There are some bad comments about smudges and scratches, but if you contact support they will help. I've received many orders of these lids in perfect condition, with a plastic cling seal on the top of the lid that I leave on for my customer to remove, so that the lid stays damage free through making the candle and transit. I did receive an order that the plastic cling protectors were a weird hard plastic that just fell off of all the lids, but support easily and quickly fixed this problem.

I received all 3 colors and not one scratch, on any of the tops. I will be ordering more soon.

These lids are great! I have been shopping for this size and they were hard to find. Thankfully ya all carried them thanks!

I was very hesitant to buy these due to that bad comments but, I received mine with no scratches no dings or marks. This was also my first time ordering these lids and jars.