We use the silver, black & bronze lids for all our 3-wicks jars. Never had a problem with scratches/rub marks and we order them by the case. Packaged well and secure.

I was so sad, after my first review, the next day they were completely out of stock! (Just my luck) However, I was over the moon to receive all of them and successfully sold all my candles. Everyone (friends and family) complemented the lids and little did they know how much that meant! Hope this review helps, all the lids came with the film cover and perfect! Just received Silver lids as well and in pristine condition love them!

For anyone who is wondering if the scuffing issue was fixed, I just ordered some lids and they came with a protective film and for the most part I haven't noticed any damages at all. Most likely will be buying again.

These lids are great! So happy to find these in this size!

I love these lids. They were exactly what I was looking for. I just hate that the lids were scuffed. out of the several dozen, I ordered almost all had a ring of scuff marks and one was dented. Don't get me wrong, I would still order again and you shouldn't stop either because these are great! I did notice the smaller ones had a plastic film that did a perfect job of protecting them. I hope they switch to those on here as well!