We use the silver, black & bronze lids for all our 3-wicks jars. Never had a problem with scratches/rub marks and we order them by the case. Packaged well and secure.

Huge thanks to the team at Candlescience! My previous review was based on my scratched and dented lids. However, after being contacted, all my issues were resolved with ease. The packing technique was different and it worked!
Thanks again Candlescience!

I ordered these lids as part of my Fall/Winter candle collection, but 6 of the 12 lids were scratched and disfigured beyond use! I'm going to try for an exchange or refund.
I hope the shipping or packing issue gets resolved soon, I really would like to have these as a permanent part of my collection.
I use the black lids normally and have not had any delivery problems. However, there was more foam covering those...?

Has anyone received their lids without scuff marks or scratches recently? Wondering if packaging of the lids has been resolved before purchasing lids.

Every lid I received today is scratched. I noticed that another review said they would have plastic separators but they are paper. This is now the third package (two bronze 3 wick and one silver 3 wick) that are scratched. I can’t use them.

All lids were scratched! They all had a thin piece of tissue paper between them but that did not prevent the scratches.

These are nice lids I had been looking for a lod to fit my libbey candle bowl 2906 and it's a perfect fit and a reasonable price

I love these lids! The only issue I have is that I ordered 2 -12 packs and could only use about 14 of them as the rest had scuff rings? I’m not sure what to call them but marks on the lids like the lid above it rubbed off on it. I can’t seem to get the marks off so I had to not use them. I will try maybe some chrome cleaner and see if that fixes the issue. I also order here in the smaller version for the other jars and they have been fine. So pretty other than that!