Are you serious? I have never smelt anything that was titled pumpkin pie before that smelt so scrumpalicious(scrumptious and delicious combined)! I love this fragrance SOOOO much! Definitely buying again next fall(I still have quite a bit left. The perfect combo of spicy, pumpkiny, pie crusty, and sweet. All those professional candle makers out there: this is a must buy. My family loves it and so do I. Super happy with this fragrance.