To set the record straight pumpkin souffle and toasted pumpkin spice are two different scents not to be compared. They are both excellent in their own way. My customers especially love the true toasted element in the Toasted Pumpkin which happens to be my number one seller. Excellent hot and cold throw in candles/melts using a blend of coconut & soy wax or paraffin & soy. For the best scents in the industry Candlescience is the Lamborghini of fragrances.