I've had nothing but a great experience with these lids, the gold is spot on in the picture. Really elevates the look of your candle! It gives some a more luxe look than other plastisol liner lids. They are gorgeous!

I love the look of these lids, but I dont like the foam under it, they are also very bendy or dont screw on the jars right at times. I like the old lids better.

I had this issue with the old jars and now it continues with the new ones.

These are beautiful lids, but they have a few issues. They bend very easily and a few times an entire pack of 12 will be crushed with other supplies we ordered in the box. Also the lids can sometimes be faulty and not stay on, or not tightly screw and they scratch very very easily. I'd love if the package came in quantities great than 12, but oh well.

75% of the lids within our very large order would not stay on, but CS is absolutely wonderful at replacing immediately. Sadly, the replacements had the same. Hoping it's just a 'bad batch' they received in. Going to reorder again to see if they are any better. Very disappointing because they really do look nice.

It would be nice if these lids came in packages larger than 12. I order a lot at a time and it is frustrating for them to be in such small bags. In addition to throwing away several thick ziplock type bags, each lid also has its own plastic cover to peel off. I'm sure this saves them from getting scratched up but like I said, it is just a lot to throw away and a good bit of extra work if you're making a lot of candles. Overall, the lids have a very nice look.

Love the look of these lids but they are so weak that they barely stay on the jar. If you twist too hard they pop off and I can use less than half of what I ordered because they won't stay secured.

I love these lids and anxiously waiting their arrival. These lids can make a plan straight edge vessel look so nice.

CS customer service is 5 stars, but I can only give this product 3 stars. I ordered 4 packages of these lids and one pack got damaged, and CS was kind enough to send a replacement. The replacement was shipped in a padded envelope and 8 of them were damaged. It seems like these lids are made of aluminum, a pretty soft metal (so soft that I can fold them in half with my weak hands with zero effort). I also accidentally scratched the lids with my nails and scratched them against the carpet when I was pulling everything out. They're beautiful and everything I'm looking for in terms of aesthetics for my candles, but it's not durable. A little torn, but will most likely purchase again because I love the way they look.

So the last review I take it all back CS fixed my problem so fast and shipped a new replacement free of charge and they all came in perfect condition. :)