#70 G Black Threaded Lid

I have been a loyal Candlescience customer since 2019. I have exclusively used these lids on my 12 Oz. canning jar candles. I have never had an issue with the hundreds of lids I have purchased. They seal nicely and any imperfection that have have ever found (which are few and far between), were so miniscule that it did not affect the integrity or look of the lid. If you are doing canning jar candles you cannot ask for a better value or a better lid. I highly recommend these lids.

I'm not sure where all of the negative reviews are coming from but every time I order these lids they come out perfect, glossy and gorgeous with no issues. Don't be swayed by these perfectionists, these lids are great.

While I absolutely love the look of these lids (the gold touch is chic), they often come scratched. I wish they were either manufactured and/or packaged better.

I have been looking for something like this for a long time! Thank goodness the white rim is gone!!!

I just switched from my current pewter lid to these black unlined lids and I couldn’t be happier with them! The color and look match my crow logo perfectly. I am buying more of these lids to swap out all my candle lids to this new look. The black lids with the white on lip didn’t look good at all against my logo as the white broke up the flow of the design. The gold compliments the rustic look of my design. Please keep them in stock!!

I like the gold!

very disappointed ): lids came all scratched up and they look and feel so much cheaper than the previous version. They were all I had so I had to use them for my customers but I hope Candle Science restocks the previous version again. Now I need to find a new supplier just for my lids ):

I absolutely love the new lids. Prior to ordering the 4oz jars for a custom order, I was using 8oz straight sided clear jars before moving over to the black tumblers. I had to go elsewhere to find these black lids with gold trim. The problem with that was that the vendor I ordered them from shipped super poorly every time and the lids came damaged. That alone caused me to change the look jars I use. So while I understand others frustration when the lids changed if they had a look based off the old ones, the gold adds a touch of chicness that the white does not. Additionally, anything with a liner absorbs scents where these do not.

We love these lids... The old ones where ok, but these new one are just the best. Thank you Candle Science for making the change.

Love these lids! So glad the white plastic on the inside is gone. The new style fits the jars so much better and does not absorb the fragrances anymore. Thank you for stocking a better product!

I have been using black lids for a few years. I have appreciated the change from the white plastisol interior to the gold. The lids are lighter (and yes, they are a little noisier), but there isn’t a visible white rim around the bottom anymore. I use clear jars, and I do not color my soy candles, so at times the white rim would clash against the natural color (especially those containing a higher vanillin content). Another dislike I had was the white plastisol inside would start yellowing/browning over time (again with heavier vanillin scents). I am overall very happy with the newer lids!

Terrible gold tinny cheap feeling

Keep the new gold trimmed lids! They give our line a clean, sophisticated look. The old ones just didn’t have that professional we look for. Candle Science is the only place I can get this black/gold top. They are great!!!

I was surprised when I received my black lid order. I recently changed my branding and did all new photography based on the black lids with the white rim that we'd always had. But then I got these and panicked!! I wish they'd bring back the other ones. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE!!

GO BACK TO WHITE INSIDES

I have been loyal customer to Candlescience, but I must agree with the other comments. I dislike this new look, I have an entire line of product based on a black and white look & this change has completely thrown it off; I have to look elsewhere to find the old lids. New lids also has a cheap look to it.

These lids are great, but I do have to say I miss the white lining. The gold is just off putting with my black and white labels. Sticking with just a pure white lid as a substitute. If I could give these lids a 5 star for how they work, I would! But they get a 3 star for the change in color. I am sure I couldn't be helped.

I just received my new order with the black lids and NOPE! They look and feel cheap. I don’t like the at all and now I have no other option than to use it for my last orders so they are not late.

These lids are now gold inside instead of white, not happy that these were changed without any notice.

GREAT LID...Finally no white edges and plastic on the inside a candle lid. Thank you for getting these.

I agree that I liked the white lining better on the old style lid. Additionally, my soap products are often kept in showers and the lid without the coating rusts. I used to allow a recycle program of the jar and lid to be returned and sterilized and now the lids are complete trash upon return. What a shame. They sound super cheap when you're opening the jars and they're easily dented now. I understand there must be an additional cost to the manufacturer but I wouls gladly pay it for the returned quality.

Please please bring back the black lid with white trim. I have to agree with the previous comments regarding the black with gold trim is horrible!

I literally designed my whole candle line aesthetic based on the black lid with the white lip. I’ll either have to find an entirely new jar or another supplier. So bummed!

Absolutely hate these new lids! I loved the fact that the other lids had a nice tight seal to them, it was perfect for my bath and body products as well as candles. Now I’ll have to use something else. Seriously disappointed in some of the changes that are being made here lately!

I have to agree with the last few comments - I hate these new lids. They look cheap, sound cheap and gold fits no where into the look of my candle line. Must work to determine if i am going back to the rustic pewter, at least those look like they are supposed to be rustic and don't look cheap. I really hate these lids.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE the old lids. No idea why it was changed but the new gold ones look, feel, and sound so cheap. I am so bummed. (they DO NOT fit the 9oz threaded jars like the example/review pics show, the old ones may have worked but the new version does not)

I dont know what caused the change but mistakes were made. These new lids are horrible. Cheap and flimsy the paint job isnt nearly as good and the gold trim is horrible.

Please bring back the old lids with the white lip and rubber lined inside. The new ones are flimsy and sound awful when twisting them on and off. The others were much classier!

I’m completely devastated that these new lids are now gold (which you can see from the outside because it has a gold lip). My brand’s aesthetic is black and white and I’ve been using these for years! I got my order in with these new ones and I can’t use them at all. It would be different if they were completely black with no gold lip at least. I would love to know where else I can get them. I’m starting not to trust Candlescience as my go to supplier. They just aren’t reliable anymore. Every scent keeps changing and now I have to hunt down some usable lids for my candle business :’(

I love the look of the black lid. Gives the candles a great classy look.

Better than others

I love these black lids with my mason jars. It gives my primitive style a modern twist!

Looks great and appealing

It makes absolutely no sense to make a black lid with white border! The inside of the lid is white and this transfers over to the edges of the black lid. So when you screw it on your mason jar, you see the clear glass, the black lid and a white strip in between. Makes no sense and looks horrible. It should all be black, inside and out.