Love these lids - simple and beautiful.

A little chunkier than expected. I also didn’t realize that the lip and inside of lid was gold. I’m still willing to work with them though, now that I have 144(lol). Not really CS’s fault. The price was my biggest reason for choosing these anyway.

I have been a loyal Candlescience customer since 2019. I have exclusively used these lids on my 12 Oz. canning jar candles. I have never had an issue with the hundreds of lids I have purchased. They seal nicely and any imperfection that have have ever found (which are few and far between), were so miniscule that it did not affect the integrity or look of the lid. If you are doing canning jar candles you cannot ask for a better value or a better lid. I highly recommend these lids.

I'm not sure where all of the negative reviews are coming from but every time I order these lids they come out perfect, glossy and gorgeous with no issues. Don't be swayed by these perfectionists, these lids are great.

While I absolutely love the look of these lids (the gold touch is chic), they often come scratched. I wish they were either manufactured and/or packaged better.

I have been looking for something like this for a long time! Thank goodness the white rim is gone!!!

I just switched from my current pewter lid to these black unlined lids and I couldn’t be happier with them! The color and look match my crow logo perfectly. I am buying more of these lids to swap out all my candle lids to this new look. The black lids with the white on lip didn’t look good at all against my logo as the white broke up the flow of the design. The gold compliments the rustic look of my design. Please keep them in stock!!

I like the gold!

very disappointed ): lids came all scratched up and they look and feel so much cheaper than the previous version. They were all I had so I had to use them for my customers but I hope Candle Science restocks the previous version again. Now I need to find a new supplier just for my lids ):

I absolutely love the new lids. Prior to ordering the 4oz jars for a custom order, I was using 8oz straight sided clear jars before moving over to the black tumblers. I had to go elsewhere to find these black lids with gold trim. The problem with that was that the vendor I ordered them from shipped super poorly every time and the lids came damaged. That alone caused me to change the look jars I use. So while I understand others frustration when the lids changed if they had a look based off the old ones, the gold adds a touch of chicness that the white does not. Additionally, anything with a liner absorbs scents where these do not.